|
Estate & Gift Taxation
Fall 1999
Professor William Metzger
The Role of State Law
Creation of Property Interest à Determined by STATE Law
State law creates the property interest during PROBATE proceeding
Decides what property is included in D’s estate
Federal Court decides how much tax is due
Proper Regard Standard à Estate of Bosch
Decision of highest State Court is FINAL
Other State Court decisions receive proper regard ONLY
Scope of the Estate Tax
§ 2033 à
“Value of all property to the extent of the interest therein of the decedent at the time of death.”
Taxes property interest beneficially owned OR transferred by D
Taxes interests that CEASE at the time of death as opposed to what the heirs RECEIVED on account of D’s death
Beneficial Ownership à Legal ownership is NOT determinative
Includes
Interests Arising at Death à Did D have the interest at time of death ?
Wrongful death awards are NOT includible under §2033
Action arose AFTER death [or on account of death]
Measured by the LOSS to the children/spouse, NOT value of D’s life
Property OR Expectancy à [Estate of Barr]
Mere expectancy is NOT a sufficient interest to trigger §2033
Expectancy is NOT property in existence b/f death
E.g. payment in the discretion of the employer
Even if payment was actually made – D had no vested right
Bank Deposits, Checks, & Notes à Regs. §20.2031-5
Cash belonging to D on date of death is includible in estate
Exception à
Charitable contributions do NOT count as bona fide legal obligations UNLESS made pursuant to K
Scope of the Gift Tax §2501 & §2511
§2501 à
Tax imposed upon the transfer of property by gift
Direct or indirect – real or personal property [§2511(a)]
Is there a Transfer ?
Gratuitous performance of services is NOT a transfer of property w/i the meaning of §2501 [Hogle]
NEW RULE à
Taxable as if the parent charged a “fair rate of interest”
No such thing as an interest free loan under §7872
Becomes interest income to parent
Where is the money ?
Parent gifted the interest forgiven each year
Child can take interest deduction [even though none was paid]
BUT à $10,000 exemption for annual gifts anyway
No gift tax L to parent BUT there IS income
When is the Transfer Completed ?
Periodic Payments à
NOT counted as separate gifts when made
ALL will count as TOTAL amount of 1 gift
Actuarially computed present value of payments = gift
Notes & Checks à
Gift is NOT made on delivery [b/c payment can be stopped]
Gift IS made when paid, certified, accepted by drawee, OR negotiated for value to 3rd party
Transferred Interests Incapable of Valuation à
Indirect Transfers à §2511(a)
Donative intent is irrelevant – and NOT conclusive of gift
Occurs where intermediate recipient is used [Heyen]
End result is a transfer to the ultimate recipient [family member]
Common Examples à
Transfer of stock to daughter-in-law
Gift to ENTITY [corporation]
Gift from ENTITY to individual
What is a Gift ? à Regs. §25.2512-8
What is NOT a gift ? à
Transfers which EXCEED consideration given –
Transfers made in “ordinary course of business” & free from donative intent
Satisfaction of support obligation of minor – NO gift
Educational OR Medical expenses - §2503(e)
Transfers With Retained Powers & Rights §2036-§2038
Purpose of the Sections à Prevent individuals from avoiding the generally higher estate tax L by making testamentary transfers in the form of lifetime gifts.
Transfers With Retained Life Estates §2036
Elements (3) à §2036
Transfer – By D to another person
Retains for life OR any period not ascertainable w/o reference to his death – INCOME portion
Exception – Bona fide sale for adequate & full consideration
Possession or Enjoyment OR Right to Income– Retained by D
Applies to possession or enjoyment of INCOME portion
Need NOT amount to a legal life estate [Nicol]
Lease may equal the right to income
The RIGHT, either alone or in conjunction w/another person to designate the B §2036(a)(2)
Power to accumulate income = power to designate B
Even if power is held in conjunction w/other trustees
Adverse interest of other trustees is irrelevant
OR
How much is includible ? à “… to the extent of any interest therein…”
If PORTION [e.g. life estate] is retained – PORTION includible §2036(a)(1)
Legally enforceable interest is irrelevant
Agreement may be inferred – need NOT be in writing
Secondary Life Estates à E.g. grantor transfers property in trust
To W for life, then to grantor, then to children
Includible under §2036(a)(1)
How much ?
Settlor who IS Trustee à Must limit the discretion here to avoid §2036
Settlor who is NOT Trustee à
Trustee may have discretion to make the payout or not here
No ascertainable standard is necessary
Grantor may NOT have unrestricted power to remove trustee
Grantor may NOT have power to replace trustee – even w/another other than himself [will find another who will go his way]
Revocable Transfers §2038
Elements à
Transfer – By D [of property once owned by him] to another person
Exception – Bona fide sale for adequate & full consideration
Powers HELD [as opposed to retained under §2036] by D at death – Alter, Amend, Revoke, or Terminate OR
D does NOT need to RETAIN of enjoyment of property here
Power here pertains to the CORPUS OR INCOME
Is the enjoyment of the property subject to any change through the exercise of a power held by D ?
Power to distribute principal [timing problem here] = power to terminate [Lober]
Power is relinquished during 3 year period ending on date of D’s death
Exceptions à
Transfer for adequate & full consideration in money or money’s worth
Powers retained subject to some ascertainable standard
Power which may ONLY be exercised w/consent of all parties having an adverse interest [vested OR contingent] in the transferred property
This does NOT mean the same as alone or in conjunction w/ another person w/an adverse interest
Power held by person OTHER than grantor/decedent
Does NOT apply if D could remove Trustee
How Much is Includible ? à
Power to revoke a PORTION = portion includible
Death Benefits à
Must show D had a property interest which was transferred
Power to change B up until the time of death = includible
Counter Argument à [Tully]
Transfers With Retained Reversionary Interests §2037
Elements à
Transfer of property by D
Possession or enjoyment conditioned upon surviving D
D has retained a reversionary interest
Possibility of reversion measured ONLY at death is includible under §2037 [Thacher]
Refers to the value of the interest, NOT the amount includible in D’s estate
Measured immediately b/f death
E.g. à
NOTE: §2037 generally comes into play when D has died in the wrong order
Exception à
Transfers for adequate & full consideration
Term of years instead of measured by surviving D
Adequate & Full Consideration Problem
What is adequate & full consideration ? – unsettled by courts
§2043(a) à Partial Consideration è
Where transferor does NOT receive adequate & full consideration for the transfer of an interest in property à
§2043 allows for the taxation of ONLY the portion for which consideration was NOT adequate
E.g. à Sold remainder interest worth $100,000 at time of transfer
Only received $40,000 at time of transfer
At D’s death – remainder interest worth $150,000
$110,000 – taxable under §2043
Gift Tax Effects of Transfers w/Retained Interests or Powers
Introduction à
Levied when transferor sheds wealth (property)
Revolves around the surrender/relinquishment of dominion & control NOT the transfer of title or property
Where Powers are Retained à NO completed gift
Until transferor has no more power over the beneficial title
E.g. Holding powers over a trust, then making the trust irrevocable
NOTE à
Gift IS complete where grantor holds the power with another who has a substantial adverse interest in the property [Camp]
Gift IS complete where grantor holds a contingent reversion interest of the property measured by survival [Shaughnessy]
Annuities & Employee Benefits §2039
Elements à “S A C K”
K or Agreement – Always found
Simple understanding is enough
Someone who Survives D – survivor who is a B
Satisfied if B gets one or more payments over a period of time
String attached to D – Big issue here
Amount payable to D at time of death OR
D has a right to payment at time of death
Contributions from D – to show transfer of property owned by D
If D only paid for half & other half paid by B – 1/2 includible
IF A paid for it and is NOT a B – no §2039
Joint & Survivor Annuity à Payments to D & A
If D dies, payments continue to A
Employer Provided Annuity à §2039(b)
Funding here is by D’s employer
D dies AFTER retirement – amount becomes “payable” to D
Reading Plans Together à
E.g. à DBP with no strings to D coupled w/ Annuity to B w/string tied to D BUT no survivorship rights
Problem à Cannot read non-qualified and qualified plans together
Forfeitable Payments à
E.g. Annuity payment to B forfeitable upon her remarriage
Premature Death of Employee à
Suppose D dies prior to the ripening [annuity becoming “payable”] of his interest in the annuity payment
Joint Interests in Property §2040
Elements à Determined by State Law
Joint interest in property WITH
Held at time of death by D
Right of survivorship
General Rule à
Contribution Furnished TEST à §2040(a)
If A furnishes ALL the consideration
If A furnishes 1/2 the consideration
Examples à
Joint Bank Accounts –
W/ right of survivorship – covered by §2040
Can have any number of tenants
Typically, either tenant can withdraw the funds
Exception à
Gift Tax Effects à §2511 Creation of joint tenancy CAN be gift taxable
E.g. where A deeds property to B OR
A & B are joint tenants w/ROS – property worth $50,000
How much is Includible ? à
Powers of Appointment §2041
Elements à NO requirement that D owned the property
General Power of Appointment in D is;
Held
Exercised
Released
Lapsed
On D’s date of death
Definition à A power of appointment is; [State Law determination]
§2041(a)(2) Direct à D still has the general power of appointment at death
§2041(a)(2) Indirect à D had GPA, but not at his death [exercise, release…]
Exceptions à No General Power of Appointment found where;
Power is limited by “ascertainable standard” relating to health, education, support, or maintenance of the decedent §2041(b)(1)(A)
Jointly held powers – Exercisable ONLY in conjunction w/either the creator of the power OR person who has a substantial adverse interest in the property subject to the power §2041(b)(1)(C)
Adverse interest MUST be created simultaneously w/power & by the same instrument [Estate of Witkowski]
D exercised or released the GPA during life w/o retaining any strings [still a completed GIFT here though]
NOTE à Tax is levied on the $$, NOT on the individual §2207
Capacity to Exercise the Power à Irrelevant
Gift Taxation of GPA à §2514
Life Insurance §2042
Elements à No requirement of transfer here
D must be the insured under the policy
No inclusion where D is the owner of a policy on “A”
D possesses at least 1 incident of ownership at death
Economic Benefits or powers over the policy
Big issue here 4
Includible ? à
Amount Payable to Executor à §2042(1)
Amount Payable to Beneficiaries à §2042(2)
How Much ? à
What is Life Insurance à
Risk Distribution
Risk Shifting
Among a larger group
Incidents of Ownership à
Power to change B – regardless of ability to exercise this [Noel]
§2042 does NOT require actual ability to exercise the power
Policy Facts CONTROL – NOT Intent Facts [RI Trust]
Policy Facts
Intent Facts
Controlled Corporation –§20.2042(1)(c)(2) Incidents of ownership possessed through ownership of a controlled corporation are includible [Levy]
Transfers Within 3 Years of Death §2035
Elements à
Automatic inclusion in the gross estate for ALL gratuitous transfers w/i 3 years of death
Scope à
Any transfer of an interest covered by §2036, §2037, §2038, §2042 which if made during life would have been includible
How Much ? à
Amount of gift + amount of gift tax payment
Valuation à
Transfer of CASH
Transfer of PROPERTY INTEREST
Planning à
Payment of the gift tax from your estate is still a good idea
Estate is depleted by amount of gift + amount of tax paid
E.g. Gift of $120,000 + $60,000 gift tax paid
Estate is depleted $180,000
Tax would have been $90,000 – you paid $60,000
Savings of $30,000
Problem – Must live 3 years to take advantage of this
Disclaimers §2518
Elements à Qualified Disclaimer – Irrevocable & unqualified…
Refusal must be in writing
Received by transferor OR his legal representative OR holder of legal title of property no later than 9 months after the interest is created [or 9 months after donee turns 21]
Person must NOT have accepted the interest or any of its benefits before making the disclaimer
Interest must pass to person OTHER than person disclaiming as a result of the refusal to accept the property
Note à
This is your last chance at estate planning
State law says you cannot be forced to take property
Only surviving spouse can disclaim PART of the transfer
Person disclaiming cannot designate where it goes
CAN be controlled by D’s will or State Law
Marital Deduction §2056
Elements à
Show that D was survived by a spouse
Property interest passed from D to Spouse
Property must be a deductible interest under §20.2056(a)-2
Value of the property interest
Non-Deductible Interests à §20.2056(a)-2 No Deduction where:
Property is NOT in D’s estate
Property IS in D’s estate & qualifies for another deduction under Code
Property Destroyed
Non-deductible terminable interest
Non-Deductible Terminable Interests §20.2056(b) à No deduction
Definition à Property interest which will terminate or fail on the lapse of time or on the occurrence or failure to occur of some contingency
Reasoning à Would avoid transfer taxation to the done spouse as well – b/c would NOT be in the spouse’s estate
Statutory Exceptions to Non-Terminable Interests à
Tenancy by Entirety – created with other spouse
Power of Appointment Trust – meeting the following requirements: §20.2056(b)-5
Life Estate – donee spouse must be entitled to all of the income (or sole possession) for life, payable at least annually
GPA – Donee spouse must have a General Power, exercisable either by will or inter-vivos “alone and in all events”
No power in another – The transfer is disqualified if a person other than the donee spouse has power to appoint any part of the property to any person other than the donee spouse
Amount deductible – Entire portion that meets the above requirements is deductible as if made outright
QTIP Transfer – Qualified Terminal Interest in Property
Life Estate – Same as above
QTIP Election – Donor must affirmatively elect that the transfer qualify for marital deduction
Power of Appointment – No person (including the donee spouse) can be given power to appoint any of the property to a person other than the donee spouse
Joint & Survivor Annuities – Provided there is no B other than the donor & donor spouses
Amount Deductible – Full amount of the qualifying gift to which election pertains (not just the value of the life estate) as if the QTIP were an outright gift to the spouse
Marital Charitable Trust – A transfer to the spouse for life, remainder to charity, results in a marital deduction for the value of the donee spouse’s interest, IF deductible under §2522
LEGALNUT.COM NOTICES AND DISCLAIMERS:
Copyright Property. This outline is © copyrighted 2006 by Legalnut.com (Site). This outline, in whole or in part, may not be reproduced or redistributed without the written permission of Site. A limited license for personal academic use is permitted, as described below or in Site’s Terms and Conditions of Usage page on this site. This outline may not be posted on any other website without permission. Site reserves the exclusive right to distribute, change or modify this outline in whole or in part.
This Outlines does not constitute legal advice and is not a replacement for obtaining legal counsel.
No Warranties as to Accuracy. Site has made efforts to provide the best possible outlines, but, Site MAKES NO WARRANTIES AS TO THE ACCURACY OF THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS OUTLINE. THIS OUTLINE IS PROVIDED TO YOU ON AN AS-IS BASIS. USE IT AT YOUR OWN RISK, AND DO NOT RELY ON IT FOR LEGAL ADVICE. IF YOU NEED LEGAL HELP, PLEASE CONTACT A LICENSED AND QUALIFIED ATTORNEY IN YOUR JURISDICTION. AS THIS OUTLINE HAS BEEN WRITTEN BY A LAW STUDENT, IT MAY CONTAIN INACCURATE INFORMATION.
Students Can Not Claim This Outline As Their Own. Furthermore, some law schools have policies which permit law students to bring their self prepared course outlines into final exams. If your law school has such a policy, you are expressly prohibited from claiming this outline as your own or from representing that any of the other outlines contained on this Site are your own unless you are the author of this outline. If you are not sure of your law school's policy, you should contact the appropriate staff at your school.
Notices and Procedures for Making Claims of Copyright Infringement. If you have a claim of copyright infringement against this outline or any other content of this Site, then please see this Site’s Terms & Conditions of Use page for procedures of notifying Site of any alleged infringement. |