|
Family Law
Marriage and Relationship Between Family Law and Commercial Law
Relationships Between Marriage and Business Partnership, Marital Contracts and Commercial Contracts
Functional Relation Between Engagement, Formal Marriage, Cohabitation Contracts, Informal Marriage, and Business Partnership
Standard v. Bolin (page 2)
Although the Washington Supreme Court upholds the Common Law theory of breach of promise to marry, most states have abolished it by statute. One reason for their abolishment is that breach of promise to marry suits could cause a party to get married and then seek a no-fault divorce in order to get around the suit.
Breach of promise to marry may still be brought, however, using camouflage (i.e. fraudulent inducement to have sex, failure to disclose venereal disease, unjust enrichment to recover an engagement ring, etc… ).
Chaachou v. Chaachou (page 6)
Two people, married or not, who engage in the conduct of a business, may bring an action under partnership laws for equitable distribution of the partnership's property. Sometimes, this may result in a more equitable distribution than a divorce.
Common Law marriages were abolished by statute in 1968, however, common law marriages entered into prior to 1968 and common law marriages valid where entered were not effected.
McGehee v. McGehee (page 24)
Mrs. McGehee brought this action for the dissolution of a business partnership with her husband. As a partner, she was entitled to 50% of the partnership's property and did not need to rely on the discretion of the Chancellor, as in a divorce action.
Owens v. Owens (page 35)
Comments
Ante-nuptial Agreements: Safeguard to Deliberation, Recognition of Party Autonomy or Inappropriate Intrusion into Marital Ethics
Reynold v. Reynolds, 85 Mass 605 (1862)
Ante-Nuptial Agreement From Transcript in the Case of Ball v. Ball (page 41)
This contract would be void as against public policy if it were entered into today.
In general, most ante-nuptial agreements are followed and cases challenging them are dismissed.
Ball v. Ball (page 44)
Annulments are based on the common law, not on statutes. Furthermore, no jurisdictions in the United States have abolished annulment by Statute (note: FS § 61 applies only to divorce, not to annulment).
An annulment must be based on ground which existed prior to the marriage.
A voidable marriage is cured if it is ratified. One method of ratification is to have intercourse after the fraud has become known.
Posner v. Posner (page 50)
An ante-nuptial agreement that provides for the facilitation of divorce is against public policy because one essential of marriage is the intention to be married for life.
An ante-nuptial, however, that helps to regulate the breakup of a marriage is not against public policy, but any provisions pertaining to children are unenforceable.
Comments
Del Vecchio standards for a ante-nuptial agreement to be allowed to regulate a divorce – (1) the agreement must be fair and reasonable in its provisions, (2) it must provide full and frank disclosure of all the assets, and (3) parties must have an adequate knowledge of each others wealth.
Belcher Standard for an ante-nuptial agreement to be allowed to regulate a divorce – (1) the agreement must be fair and reasonable in its provisions, (2) it must provide full and frank disclosure of all the assets, and (3) there must be consideration.
Florida Probate Code § 732.702 says that a post-nuptial agreement must provide full and adequate disclosure of all assets, but an ante-nuptial agreement does not need to give such disclosure.
The Movement of the Progressive Societies Has Hitherto Been a Movement from Status to Contract
Ponder v. Graham (page 74)
Maynard v. Hill (page 78)
Ryan v. Ryan (page 83)
The Florida Supreme Court held that the contractual rights of marriage are inchoate rights and could therefore be regulated by the police power, subject to judicial review.
Therefore, although the legislature enacted the no-fault divorce statute, the court may still determine if there is sufficient evidence to show that the marriage is irretrievably broken.
Comments
A marriage, valid where entered, is valid everywhere in the United States unless it shocks the conscience of the state.
An ante-nuptial agreement must be in writing in Florida.
Marital Failure and the Distribution of Losses
Joint Investment in Education
Morgan v. Morgan [I] & [II] (pages 95 & 98)
O'brien v. O'brien (page 98)
Mahoney v. Mahoney (page 103)
Comments
Career Building – Individual or Shared Gain?
Thompson v. Thompson (page 115)
The value of a Professional Association can be valued by determining the value of its tangible assets plus goodwill.
The value of the assets of the business plus goodwill not attributed to the talent of the husband could be considered when determining marital property.
Elkus v. Elkus (page 117)
A New York court included the wife's talent as an opera singer because her husband expended considerable efforts in advancing her career.
In Florida, the court would only consider the wife's career in determining the equitable distribution.
Marriage Partnership as a Liability
Kennedy v. Nelson (page 133)
Connor v. S.W. Florida Regional, 668 So. 2d 175 (FL 1995)
Northampton Brewery Corporation v. Lande (page 135)
Determining What Assets May be Divided as Marital Property
In re Marriage of Grubb (page 140)
Smith v. Lewis (page 144)
Informal Marriage: State Withdrawal or State Intrusion?
Common Law Marriage
Substantive Versus Procedural Marriage
Marriage by Presumption (page 161)
Campbell v. Christian (page 161)
Religious and Ethnic Factors
Parkinson v. J. & S. Tool Company (page 172)
Court held that good faith reliance on a priest's counsel was enough to legitimatize a marriage for the purpose of worker's compensation.
The court allowed for a de facto marriage to satisfy the worker's compensation statutes even though no de jure marriage existed.
De jure – In Law
De facto – In Fact
Florida may use Marriage by estoppel to prevent one party from bringing the no marriage defense if that party procured the marriage under false or misleading pretenses.
Presumptions are like bats… …they flitter in the twilight and disappear in the bright light of day.
Other Informal Marriages for Limited Purposes
Putative Marriage
|